ABSTRACT

Clash of the Trinities: A New Theoretical Analysis of the General Nature of War   [open pdf - 2MB]

"Major Daniel Maurer begins assembling his framework by respectfully questioning the received wisdom that Clausewitz was the last and most comprehensive word on the subject of war's underlying nature. First, despite some common ground regarding the relevance of war's political basis, he finds no consensus (no 'unified field theory') among practitioners, presidents, political scientists, sociologists, or historians-from Clausewitz to Wylie to Keegan-that satisfactorily accounts for all of war's varying shades, and which legitimately recognizes its basic elemental components, its evolving character, and the 'Why?' that animates or inspires parties to engage in conflict. Noting that not even the U.S. Department of Defense has a doctrinal definition of war, Major Maurer cross-examines some well-known and entrenched interpretations, including those of H. R. McMaster, Rupert Smith, and Emile Simpson, in the hope of reconciling their differences and linking their similarities with a view toward a new explanation that is consonant with descriptions and forecasts of wars-past, present, and future. Second, Maurer moves through and past Clausewitz, piercing the Clausewitzian trinity of passion, reason, and chance to unearth even more elemental components that comprise war regardless of scale. To accomplish this, Maurer embarks on a wholly original avenue of approach: thinking about war from the 'perspectives of compounding relevant points of view existing simultaneously and in concert,' what he analogizes to a musical fugue. This fugue of war, like its musical counterpart, is governed by a repeating theme-here, Maurer proposes choice as that single, dominating trait that defines war at any scale, imagined or studied."

Author:
Publisher:
Date:
2017-09
Copyright:
Public Domain
Retrieved From:
U.S. Army War College Strategic Studies Institute: http://ssi.armywarcollege.edu/
Format:
pdf
Media Type:
application/pdf
URL:
Help with citations