ABSTRACT

Intelligence Analysis in Theater Joint Intelligence Centers: An Experiment in Applying Structured Methods   [open pdf - 777KB]

"In clear, articulate, unmistakable language, Master Sergeant Folker's learned thesis sets forth the key opposing arguments in the long-standing controversy over the role of structuring in intelligence analysis. The controversy is largely one-sided, because proponents of intuitive analysis see no purpose in debating the issue, as they are completely satisfied with the status quo. It is only the structuring enthusiasts who see a need for drastic change in the way analysis is conducted. Because, as Folker points out, supporters of the status quo include not only most analysts but most commanders as well, the structuring enthusiasts have never made progress in reforming the other side. And they won't make any progress until the superiority of structured analysis over intuitive analysis is proved, which Folker has taken a first giant step in doing. And it is precisely on this point that Folker challenges the Intelligence Community-- indeed the entire U.S. government and the private sector as well--to design and conduct reliable tests to demonstrate which analytic approach is superior: structured or intuitive. Given the wide range of available structuring techniques, each one should be tested in competition with intuition."

Report Number:
JMIC Occasional Paper No.7
Publisher:
Date:
2000-01
Copyright:
Public Domain
Retrieved From:
National Defense Intelligence College: http://www.ndic.edu
Format:
pdf
Media Type:
application/pdf
URL:
Help with citations